← Small democracy: the whole story

Sources

Every statement on Small democracy: the whole story, with what backs it and how far each source was checked. A level says how far the work was read, never how strong the claim is.

verified 49secondary 48computed 7tertiary 3not read 1recalled 1

109 sources and quotations; 4 of 67 statements have none recorded yet.

Democracy started small, and it grew

No source recorded yet.

And what happens to big democracy if there is no small democracy?

No source recorded yet.

How might we recognise democracy if we see it?

A written record
  • verified If the society has auditors the report should be handed to them, with the vouchers, in time to be audited before the meeting. §62 Treasurer; Robert's Rules of Order Revised (1915), public-domain text as published by the Constitution Society, http://www.constitution.org/rror/rror.htm; local copy reference/robert-rules-of-order-revised-1915.txt, Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • verified The secretary is the recording officer of the assembly and the custodian of its records except such as are specifically assigned to others, as the treasurer's books. These records are open, however, to inspection by any member at reasonable times §59 Secretary, or Clerk; Robert's Rules of Order Revised (1915), public-domain text as published by the Constitution Society, http://www.constitution.org/rror/rror.htm; local copy reference/robert-rules-of-order-revised-1915.txt, Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • verified Yearly Meeting manuscript minutes vol 1(1672–1693) Notes and references, 1.04 ¶1 (and 19.34), Quaker Faith & Practice, 5th edition (Britain Yearly Meeting)
  • verified Companies Act 2006
  • secondary Claim C-203: The markers of small democracy: six things a member experiences
A practice of deciding together
  • verified When a motion relating to a certain subject contains several parts, each of which is capable of standing as a complete proposition if the others are removed, it can be divided into two or more propositions to be considered and voted on as distinct questions §24 Division of a Question, and Consideration by Paragraph; Robert's Rules of Order Revised (1915), public-domain text as published by the Constitution Society, http://www.constitution.org/rror/rror.htm; local copy reference/robert-rules-of-order-revised-1915.txt, Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • verified No member shall speak more than twice during the same day to the same question (only once on an appeal), nor longer than ten minutes at one time, without leave of the assembly §42 Debate; Robert's Rules of Order Revised (1915), public-domain text as published by the Constitution Society, http://www.constitution.org/rror/rror.htm; local copy reference/robert-rules-of-order-revised-1915.txt, Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • verified Before any subject is open to debate it is necessary, first, that a motion be made by a member who has obtained the floor; second, that it be seconded (with certain exceptions); and third, that it be stated by the chair, that is, by the presiding officer. §2 What Precedes Debate; Robert's Rules of Order Revised (1915), public-domain text as published by the Constitution Society, http://www.constitution.org/rror/rror.htm; local copy reference/robert-rules-of-order-revised-1915.txt, Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • verified it was during the years 1667–1669 that George Fox journeyed throughout the country, creating from a series of ad hoc meetings a regular structure of monthly and quarterly meetings as part of a yearly meeting ch. 19, the paragraph introducing 19.49, Quaker Faith & Practice, 5th edition (Britain Yearly Meeting)
  • verified Fox, Journal, ch. 17 (the setting up of the monthly and quarterly meetings, 1667–69)
  • verified Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • secondary Claim C-203: The markers of small democracy: six things a member experiences
Rules the members own
Officers who answer to the members
  • verified Toulmin Smith, English Gilds (1870, Early English Text Society) — ordinances read in print
  • verified And once in the year a feast shall be held, and fresh wardens … shall be chosen by the … and a true account shall be … newly chosen wardens of all that has been done on behalf of … the gild during the last year. p. 139, Gild of the Lord's Prayer, York (the editor's English rendering of the 1389 return), Toulmin Smith, English Gilds (1870, Early English Text Society) — ordinances read in print
  • verified If the society has auditors the report should be handed to them, with the vouchers, in time to be audited before the meeting. §62 Treasurer; Robert's Rules of Order Revised (1915), public-domain text as published by the Constitution Society, http://www.constitution.org/rror/rror.htm; local copy reference/robert-rules-of-order-revised-1915.txt, Robert's Rules of Order — and the reconsider and rescind motions
  • secondary Claim C-203: The markers of small democracy: six things a member experiences
  • secondary Three primary texts for the markers: Friendly Societies Act 1793; The Cambridge Platform (1648), ch. 8; Anderson's Constitutions of the Free-Masons (1723), General Regulations
Equal standing
A covenant

Big democracy

509 BC: Rome becomes a republic
508 BC: Athens
930: Iceland's Althing
1265: Parliament
1291: Swiss cantons
1581: The Dutch Republic
1689: Bill of Rights
  • verified That Election of Members of Parlyament ought to be free. Declaration of rights, Bill of Rights 1688/9
  • verified That the Freedome of Speech and Debates or Proceedings in Parlyament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any Court or Place out of Parlyament. Declaration of rights, Bill of Rights 1688/9
1776–1789: Revolutions
1800–1827: A world of monarchies
1828–1913: The first wave
1914–1921: War, and the vote for women
1922–1942: The reverse wave
  • secondary Huntington, 'Democracy's Third Wave' (Journal of Democracy 2(2), 1991) and The Third Wave (1991) — wave dates 1828–1926, 1922–42, 1943–62, 1958–75, from 1974
1943–1957: The second wave
1958–1973: Coups, and the last barriers fall
1974–2005: The third wave
2006–2025: The democratic recession

Small democracy

1580s–1650s: Dissenting congregations
1889–1920: Mass membership, then the vote
c.1300: Florence and the Hansa
1179: Guilds: organised, but closed
1844–1888: The craft spreads
1800–1843: Practising democracy before having the vote
1793: Friendly societies recognised
1620: The Mayflower Compact
1633: The first town meeting
1639: Towns make a colony
1772–1773: The towns answer Boston
1620–1799: Towns before the nation
  • secondary Dataset: First elected assemblies of the American colonies, 1619–1751 — our compilation
  • computed Dataset: New England towns, 1620–1921: each Massachusetts and Connecticut town with its founding year and location — our compilation

From the room to the republic

How one layer was built

No source recorded yet.

1415–1541: Out of the mist
1550–1565: Refugee churches
1581: A congregation that governs itself
1608: Exile in the Dutch Republic
1620: The covenant becomes a government (our reading, not a finding)
1633: The town meeting
1639: Layers: towns make a colony
1647: Back in England: the demand
1652–1682: The Quakers: decisions without votes
  • verified Quaker Faith & Practice, 5th edition (Britain Yearly Meeting)
  • verified it was during the years 1667–1669 that George Fox journeyed throughout the country, creating from a series of ad hoc meetings a regular structure of monthly and quarterly meetings as part of a yearly meeting ch. 19, the paragraph introducing 19.49, Quaker Faith & Practice, 5th edition (Britain Yearly Meeting)
1700s: A landscape of small republics
1772–1774: The structure carries the resistance
1776–1789: A nation built on top of the towns (our reading, not a finding)
1828–1840: Mass democracy, and a nation of joiners
  • verified Town-meetings are to liberty what primary schools are to science; they bring it within the people’s reach, they teach men how to use and how to enjoy it. Vol. 1, Book I, ch. V (Reeve translation, Gutenberg text 815). The Gutenberg HTML carries no print page numbers, so the chapter is the finest locator honestly available., Democracy in America
  • secondary Huntington, 'Democracy's Third Wave' (Journal of Democracy 2(2), 1991) and The Third Wave (1991) — wave dates 1828–1926, 1922–42, 1943–62, 1958–75, from 1974
  • computed Dataset: V-Dem Dataset v16 (2026): country-year regime, suffrage and civil-society indicators — our calculations
1867–1960: The federated century

Back to the big picture: the last sixty years

No source recorded yet.

The rooms we can count

  • computed Dataset: The rooms series — our compilation of member-governed local bodies in Britain, from the Certification Officer, Cole, Ekberg, the Methodist Conference, Hansard, Plunkett, the FCA and the Bank of England

The craft, element by element

Our reading, not a finding.
  • secondary Claim C-202: Platforms are designed to remove the association

What the numbers show

1. Fewer rooms, more members
3. Heads without bodies
4. How many people actually decide?
  • secondary Real Democracy
  • secondary Participation snapshots: co-op meeting attendance 1933 (Spear 2004), Vermont town meetings 1970–98 (Bryan 2004), Co-op Group AGM 2015, credit union elections
Two tests from the Arab world
Civil society and democracy, 1913–2019

What the sixty years show

Our reading, not a finding.

Which of these do you actually experience?

Appendix: the data