Small democracy · the whole story

Democracy started small, and it grew

The story of democracy is normally told as one of nations. One of grand actions: revolutions, declarations and constitutions. When we think about democracy, we think of political speeches and votes.

But democracy goes much deeper. Democracy started small, and it grew. It starts in rooms where ordinary people learned to decide things together.

μ.democracy.

And what happens to big democracy if there is no small democracy? What happens when the rooms of people making decisions together empty?

The question for anyone who believes in democracy: how many of the decisions in your life are democratic? Are you ever in the room where the craft of democracy is learnt?

Here's a little story of how democracy grew from small to big. We begin with the story of democratic nations, but then we look underneath, at the small democracy that could just be the engine.

This is built from data, but it's still very much a research project, with lots more to learn.

How might we recognise democracy if we see it?

It's not that difficult, but the question is… have you ever actually seen it? Six things mark a group that governs itself. They don't mean voting on everything. Groups have always had officers; what matters is that the officers answer to the members.

  1. Clear and recorded decisions

    1. A written record

      What was decided is written down where every member can read it: the decision, why, and what was done, money included. Without the record nobody can check anything else, so this is where the practice starts.

      1389: English guild wardens render a true account of all that has been done on behalf of the guild. 1672: the Quakers' Yearly Meeting keeps written minutes of its decisions, and has kept them since. 2006: British company law requires the minutes of every directors' meeting to be kept for ten years (Companies Act s.248).

    2. A practice of deciding together

      When something needs deciding, the group works it through together: the different decisions tangled up in it are unpicked, each question is put clearly, everyone is listened to, and someone holds the process so the group can tell when it has arrived. The rules say how a decision is made; this is the skill of making one, and it is learned by doing.

      408/7 BC: the Athenian assembly accepts the Council's proposal but corrects one word of it before it is carved. 2013: Britain's Quakers tell their clerks that a minute is only a draft until the meeting has accepted it as its own.

  2. Rules created by the members

    1. Rules the members own

      The rules belong to the members: written down, known to everyone, and changed only by the members, in a way they agreed. They include the rules for deciding: who can propose, how a question is discussed, and when it counts as decided. The method can be a vote or the sense of the meeting; what matters is that everyone knows it.

      1667–69: George Fox sets up a regular structure of monthly and quarterly meetings for Quakers, 'gospel order'. 1793: British law lets a friendly society change its rules only at a general meeting, with three-quarters of those present agreeing. 1876: Robert's Rules of Order gives any American society a written procedure it can adopt as its own.

    2. Officers who answer to the members

      Groups need people to act for them. The members choose them, know what they handed over, can see what they did, and can take it back. Someone other than the officer checks the account.

      1389: guild wardens are chosen afresh every year. 1648: the Cambridge Platform tells New England's churches that the power to choose an officer is the power to remove one. 1844: at their first general meeting the Rochdale Pioneers appoint two auditors.

  3. Clear membership and purpose

    1. Equal standing

      Once inside, no member's voice counts for more than another's, whatever they own or however long they have belonged.

      1723: the Freemasons' constitutions give 'each Member having one Vote'. Quaker meetings go further, and reach unity without voting at all.

    2. A covenant

      The group states what it is for, and everyone knows who has bound themselves to it: how you join and how you leave. The purpose sets which decisions belong to the members. A group that cannot say what it is for, or who belongs, cannot say whose decision it is.

      1389: no one is let into the York Gild of the Lord's Prayer until the wardens have questioned them. 1581: Browne's church in Norwich gathers by covenant. 1620: the Mayflower signers 'covenant and combine' 'for our better ordering and preservation'. 1844: the Rochdale Pioneers open their rule book with its objects.

The test for every one of them is the same, and it comes from the practice of housing co-operatives today: do people know how decisions are made? The written record is where the others get tested: it is what makes the money visible.

Sources and how far each was checked (25)

All sources for this page

Big democracy

This is the story democracy usually gets: nations, arriving in waves and falling back. In 1800 one country passed the test and almost nobody could vote. By 2000 more than half the world's people could vote in a democracy. It is a story told from the top, through constitutions, elections and the franchise. It cannot show what those democracies stood on. The next map looks underneath.

–democracies
–of people could vote in one

Draft. A country lights up when it counts as a democracy on the Boix–Miller–Rosato test (contested elections, with most men able to vote). Its colour shows the share of adults with the legal right to vote: pale grey means few, ink means everyone. Data: V-Dem v16. Modern borders throughout, except the United States, drawn as the states it had each year (from the Newberry Library’s Atlas of Historical County Boundaries, CC BY-NC-SA). After 2020 the map holds each country's 2020 status. Wave dates follow Huntington.

Sources and how far each was checked (18)

All sources for this page

Small democracy

Before most people could vote, many were already governing something together. In New England, 295 towns ran their own affairs by town meeting before there was a United States. In Britain, friendly societies, co-ops and unions held more than five million memberships by 1884, when just over a third of adults could vote. The practice came first. Whether it made the national democracies possible is the question the rest of this story asks.

–democracies
–of people could vote in one

Draft. How to read the map: the pins before 1620 are dated events, not counts. From 1620 to 1800 each dot is a New England town in the year it was founded (Massachusetts and Connecticut only; Massachusetts years are incorporation, many Connecticut years settlement), and each square a colony's first elected assembly. From 1801 each bubble is a movement's memberships, not people: someone in two societies counts twice. Bubbles are interpolated between sourced data points (friendly societies, co-ops, unions, credit co-ops, the Grange, the Knights of Labor). The map stops in 1920; what happened to these bodies afterwards is the last chapter.

Sources and how far each was checked (30)

All sources for this page

From the room to the republic

The last map showed that the practice came first. This part follows one line of it, from the room up. Dissenting congregations in Europe learned to govern themselves by covenant. Their people carried it to New England, where it became the town meeting. Towns sent deputies to their colony, and colonies sent delegates to a congress, until a republic stood on top of them. Not every link is traced yet: the earliest steps are shown as mist.

A written recordA practice of deciding togetherRules the members ownOfficers who answer to the membersEqual standingA covenant

How one layer was built

Watch two things. The panel shows who decided, at each level. The strip above tracks the craft: the six things people in the room knew how to do. The same test every time: did people know how decisions were made?

Decision layerstop ↓ bottom

Nation: others decide for them e.g. elected representatives
Local meeting: everyone in the room decides e.g. a town meeting

members decide togetherothers decide for themdemandedstill being traced

Use Next and Back, or the arrow keys, to move through the story.

Sources and how far each was checked (28)

Our reading, not a finding: 1620: The covenant becomes a government; 1776–1789: A nation built on top of the towns.

All sources for this page

Back to the big picture: the last sixty years

Big democracy looks stronger than ever. More democracies than at any time in history, and everyone can vote. But underneath, the rooms have been emptying. What took their place are ways of getting other people to act for us.

This section shows it three ways: what has taken the place of each of the six marks, four measures of the emptying, and two tests of what follows when the rooms are gone.

The rooms we can count

Nobody counts who was in the room. But we can count the rooms, and most of them are gone.

  • Friendly societies. In 1911 Britain had 27,458 friendly societies and branches, each with its own officers, meetings and accounts. By 1950 there were 15,226. Today about a hundred friendly societies remain, and nobody counts their branches.
  • Co-operatives. Around 1903 there were about 1,450 co-operative societies, each governed by its own members. By 2021 there were 15: ninety-nine in every hundred gone.
  • Methodist chapels. When the Methodist churches united in 1932 they had some 14,000 chapels. In 2024 there were 3,688: more than 10,000 rooms gone, three in every four.
  • Trade unions. Around 1920 the Webbs guessed there were as many as 50,000 union branches; nobody counts them now. The unions themselves: 502 in 1983, 131 today.

The chart starts on a log scale, so that bodies counted in tens and in tens of thousands fit on one page and their shapes can be compared. A log scale makes every fall look smaller than it is. When the years have played through, the chart switches to plain counts, and the Methodist drop shows at its real size: three chapels in four.

They went for different reasons. The state took over the friendly societies' work. The co-operative societies merged. Congregations drifted away. The unions merged into a few large ones. The result was the same: fewer places where ordinary people learned to govern something together.

Not every line falls. Baptist churches held at about 3,200 for a century. A count of churches does not say who is still in them.

New rooms are opening: community shops, community pubs and community energy groups. In 2023 there were 424 community shops. They are counted in hundreds; the old rooms were counted in tens of thousands.

2026

A room counted is not a room attended: even at the peak, most members never went to a meeting. Some of the fall is mergers rather than closures. A dotted stretch means no source we have read gives those years. Every figure is downloadable with its source, including the ones we did not plot: rooms.csv.

Sources and how far each was checked (1)
  • computed Dataset: The rooms series — our compilation of member-governed local bodies in Britain, from the Certification Officer, Cole, Ekberg, the Methodist Conference, Hansard, Plunkett, the FCA and the Bank of England

All sources for this page

The craft, element by element

Take the six marks again. On the left, what a member of a self-governing group could count on. On the right, what most of the groups we belong to now offer in its place: the club run from a mailing list, the platform, the large co-op run by its staff. This is our illustration, not a measurement.

  • A written record the record is the company’s
  • A practice of deciding together the loudest voice wins, or nothing is decided
  • Rules the members own terms of service, updated without you
  • Officers who answer to the members about 3% vote; staff stay; the brief unwritten
  • Equal standing one share, one vote; or no vote
  • A covenant a mission statement nobody voted on; a mailing list, a login
Sources and how far each was checked (1)
  • secondary Claim C-202: Platforms are designed to remove the association

Our reading, not a finding: The craft, element by element.

All sources for this page

What the numbers show

Nobody counts who was in the room, so these are the nearest measures there are. The first four point the same way: fewer rooms with more members in each, fewer of the bodies that needed members to serve as officers, more organisations run by staff, and very few members taking part in deciding. The last two are tests of what follows. In the Arab world in 2011, the one uprising that produced a democracy was the one with a member-run body underneath it. And across the world since 1913, civil society and democracy have moved together.

1. Fewer rooms, more members

US credit unions: the number of member-run boards fell by two-thirds after 1990 while membership more than doubled. UK retail co-operative societies went from about 1,400 in 1900 to 47 in 2000. We count members. Nobody counts who was in the room.

Sources: NCUA historical data 1935–2025; Cole, A Century of Co-operation (1944); Ekberg (2012). Benchmark points, not a continuous series.

2. The organisations that needed officers shrank

Unions, lodges, friendly-society branches and PTAs ran on members taking turns as officers. Union density across the OECD halved from 30% in 1985 to 15% in 2024. UK union membership peaked at 13.2 million in 1979. The US PTA fell from 12 million in 1964 to 5 million by 1982.

Sources: OECD/AIAS ICTWSS; UK Department for Business and Trade; Putnam, Bowling Alone.

3. Heads without bodies

Over the same years the number of national associations in the US nearly quadrupled, from 5,843 in 1959 to 22,259 in 1990. The new ones are run by staff. Members are names on a mailing list who send money. Someone acts on your behalf. You are not in the room.

Source: Encyclopedia of Associations counts, as compiled in Skocpol, Diminished Democracy (2003).

4. How many people actually decide?

Nobody has kept a continuous record of who takes part. There are snapshots, and they all point the same way. The town meeting, where everyone present decides, is the high case. Big consumer co-ops were never high: attendance was already 1.5–5% in 1933. The Co-op Group's 2015 AGM drew about 3% of its members.

Sources: Spear 2004; Bryan 2004; Co-op Group 2015; American Banker. Snapshots, stated as such.

Two tests from the Arab world

Iraq, 2003. America declares Saddam gone and a democracy born. But the rooms underneath had been emptied for thirty years. The Ba'ath had merged every union, guild and association into the state, and after 1991 rebuilt tribal patronage in their place. The new NGOs were extensions of tribes, factions and families. Nothing for a democracy to stand on. V-Dem has never counted Iraq as one.

The Arab Spring, 2011. Six uprisings, one democracy. Tunisia had a body with rooms: the UGTT, a union founded in 1946 with half a million members in local branches, the only organisation that rivalled the ruling party in everyday life. In the uprising it was the branches that moved, not the leaders. When the transition nearly collapsed in 2013, the union and three other member bodies brokered the settlement. Egypt had the square and no body behind it; the army took it back in 2013. Libya, Syria and Yemen, where every intermediate body had been banned or absorbed, went to war.

The sting. Tunisia slipped back after 2021. One layer, inherited and thinning, was not enough. The rooms have to be kept. And the whole wave was summoned by phone: a mass could fill a square in days, but a mass cannot deliberate or decide.

V-Dem v16 regime category (v2x_regime), 2000–2025. Germany and Japan in 1945 are the counter-case: democracy declared by an occupier, but Germany had an associational world to rebuild on. Iraq is over-determined (de-Ba'athification, the army, neighbours, oil), and Tunisia had other advantages (small army, no oil); the pairing is a test, not a proof. Sources: Zubaida 2003; Carnegie 2003, 2014; Bishara 2016; PRIO 2015; Putnam 1993.

Civil society and democracy, 1913–2019

V-Dem v16, world average weighted by population: civil society participation (v2x_cspart) and electoral democracy (v2x_polyarchy), 1913–2019. The 1925–43 fall is a war; the 2012–19 fall is peacetime.

Sources and how far each was checked (18)

All sources for this page

What the sixty years show

The craft of acting together has fallen away. In its place: ways of getting other people to act for us. A professional staff. A platform. A vote every few years. Civil society hasn't disappeared. It has changed shape, from bodies with members who decide into heads without bodies.

Weimar is the warning of what dense association without the craft can do: clubs everywhere, split into sealed camps, captured one by one. Representation on its own can't hold a democracy up. People making decisions together, in layers, can. Iraq and the Arab Spring, above, are the same lesson in our own time.

In a crisis, the top centralises. That is normal. In the war, Britain censored the press and held no election for ten years; what made it temporary was the rooms underneath. Civil society participation in Britain rose through the war. In 1945 the rooms were full, and the return overshot: by 1948 France, Belgium and Norway were more democratic than before the war. The Depression was the fork. America centralised and built rooms, six thousand credit unions by 1952. Germany centralised and dissolved them. Only one came back.

Why did democracy go on spreading for forty years while the rooms emptied? The emptying began in the old democracies, and its effect comes late: people who had learned the craft went on running things for a generation after the rooms they learned it in had gone. The timing fits that reading. It cannot prove it.

Today's fall is different. It is peacetime. Since 2012 the share of people living in a democracy, as V-Dem classifies regimes, has fallen from 52% to 27%, and participation in civil society has fallen with it, the biggest drop since the 1930s, with no crisis to return from. Where it has bounced, in Poland in 2023 and Brazil in 2022, it was mobilised associations that brought it back, not the state. The top didn't fail on its own. It lost what it stood on.

The skills were never lost for good. They were found again in Norwich in 1581, in Dorchester in 1633, in Rochdale in 1844, in a thousand Grange halls. They were forgotten each time deciding together was handed to someone else. They can be remembered again.

Sources and how far each was checked (9)

Our reading, not a finding: What the sixty years show.

All sources for this page

Which of these do you actually experience?

Think of one group you belong to. A club, a congregation, a co-op, a union branch, a residents' association, your workplace. Tick what is true for you there.

These six are our reading of what keeps coming back, across seven centuries of groups that governed themselves, from the 1389 guild returns to Rochdale. It is a bet built on firm ground, not a proof: see the evidence notes. No survey asks these questions. That is itself a finding. Nothing you tick here is stored or sent anywhere.

Sources and how far each was checked (24)

All sources for this page

μ.democracy teaches the craft of small democracy.

The craft starts with writing decisions down and it grows from there. How do we define our own rules? How can we define our purpose and membership?

Democracy is more than politicians and voting. It needs to be lived. Democracy starts with you.

Start today.

Write down the next decision your group makes.Four questions, one page.Get started in 5 minutes.

Learn to record a decision

Develop the muscle.

Then the rules, the purpose, the membership.Each guide is a single A4.One mark at a time.

Find more μ.democracy guides

Find the others.

Learn from others.Teach what you know.Get support when it's difficult.

Join the community

Appendix: the data

Everything the maps and charts draw is a file you can download. Our own compilations are CC BY 4.0: use them, cite μDemocracy.org. Two are derived from others' data and carry those licences.

  • markers.csv — the markers of small democracy: 26 organisations, one row per organisation and mark, with method, source, quote, grade, warrant and independent check. CC BY 4.0. How it was made is the appendix above.
  • sixty-years.csv — the series behind the last-sixty-years charts: credit unions, co-operative societies, union density, associations, the PTA, the Arab Spring regimes, world civil-society and electoral-democracy averages, participation snapshots; one row per series, entity and year, each with its source and warrant. CC BY 4.0; the V-Dem-derived rows CC BY-SA 4.0.
  • new-england-towns.csv — 529 Massachusetts and Connecticut towns with founding year and location (coordinates from the US Census 2024 Gazetteer, public domain). CC BY 4.0.
  • colonial-assemblies.csv — each colony's first elected assembly, dated and placed, with a source and a checked level per row. CC BY 4.0.
  • colonial-franchise.csv — published estimates of who could vote in the colonies, with who made each estimate and how far it was checked. CC BY 4.0.
  • vdem-country-year.csv — our extract of the V-Dem Dataset v16 (2026): ten variables, every country-year 1789–2025 (1.4 MB). CC BY-SA 4.0, V-Dem's licence; cite V-Dem Institute, V-Dem Dataset v16, doi:10.23696/vdemds26. The big-democracy map's counts and shares are computed from this file, and a script rebuilds them on every change.
  • us-states.json — US state boundaries by date, simplified from the Newberry Library's Atlas of Historical County Boundaries. CC BY-NC-SA, the Newberry's licence.
  • The land and country outlines are Natural Earth (public domain) via topojson/world-atlas 110m.

Each file is also attached to its source record in our corpus, and the published copy is checked byte for byte against the attachment.

Sources and how far each was checked (8)

All sources for this page