The craft of acting together has fallen away. In its place: ways of getting other people to act for us. A professional staff. A platform. A vote every few years. Civil society hasn't disappeared. It has changed shape, from bodies with members who decide into heads without bodies.
Weimar is the warning of what dense association without the craft can do: clubs everywhere, split into sealed camps, captured one by one. Representation on its own can't hold a democracy up. People making decisions together, in layers, can. Iraq and the Arab Spring, above, are the same lesson in our own time.
In a crisis, the top centralises. That is normal. In the war, Britain censored the press and held no election for ten years; what made it temporary was the rooms underneath. Civil society participation in Britain rose through the war. In 1945 the rooms were full, and the return overshot: by 1948 France, Belgium and Norway were more democratic than before the war. The Depression was the fork. America centralised and built rooms, six thousand credit unions by 1952. Germany centralised and dissolved them. Only one came back.
Why did democracy go on spreading for forty years while the rooms emptied? The emptying began in the old democracies, and its effect comes late: people who had learned the craft went on running things for a generation after the rooms they learned it in had gone. The timing fits that reading. It cannot prove it.
Today's fall is different. It is peacetime. Since 2012 the share of people living in a democracy, as V-Dem classifies regimes, has fallen from 52% to 27%, and participation in civil society has fallen with it, the biggest drop since the 1930s, with no crisis to return from. Where it has bounced, in Poland in 2023 and Brazil in 2022, it was mobilised associations that brought it back, not the state. The top didn't fail on its own. It lost what it stood on.
The skills were never lost for good. They were found again in Norwich in 1581, in Dorchester in 1633, in Rochdale in 1844, in a thousand Grange halls. They were forgotten each time deciding together was handed to someone else. They can be remembered again.